| 12.1 | General:
|
| |
| 12.1.1 |
Enforcement
in the High Court is governed by CPR Parts 70 and 74 together with
RSC Orders 17, 45 to 47 and 52 as in Schedule 1 to the CPR.
|
| 12.1.2 |
RSC
O. 45 deals with enforcement generally. A judgment or order for
payment of money (other than into court) may be enforced by a writ of
Fieri Facias, Third Party Debt Order Third Party Debt Order, a
Charging Order or the appointment of a receiver. A judgment or order to do or abstain from doing an act may be enforced by a writ of
sequestration (with the permission of the court) or an order of
committal. A judgment or order for possession of land may be enforced
by a writ of possession, and a judgment or order for delivery of
goods without the alternative of paying their value by a writ of
specific delivery. In each case, where RSC O.45 r.5 applies
enforcement may also be by a writ of sequestration or an order of
committal.
|
|
| 12.2 | Writs
of execution:
|
| |
| 12.2.1 |
RSC
O.46 deals with writs of execution generally. Rules 2 and 3 set out
the circumstances when permission to issue a writ is necessary. Rule
4 contains provisions for making an application for permission. Rule
5 deals with applications for permission to issue a writ of
sequestration. RSC O. 47 contains provisions concerning writs of
Fieri Facias. Forms of writs of execution may be used as follows:
| | |
| (1) |
writs of Fieri Facias in form Nos. 53 to 63,
| | (2) |
writs of delivery in form Nos. 64 and 65,
| | (3) |
writs of possession in form Nos. 66 and 66A,
| | (4) |
writ of sequestration in form No. 67,
| | (5) |
writ of restitution in form No. 68,
| | (6) |
writ of assistance in form No. 69.
|
|
| 12.2.2 |
With
certain exceptions, writs of execution issued in the Royal Courts of
Justice are executed by the High Court Enforcement Officer. RSC O.46
r.6 sets out the provisions for issue of writs of execution. In the
Queen's Bench Division writs of execution are issued in the Central
Office in Room E15-E17. Before the Writ can be sealed for issue, a
signed praecipe for its issue must be filed in one of forms PF 86 to
90, as appropriate, stamped with the appropriate fee. A copy of the judgment or order requiring enforcement should also be provided.
|
| 12.2.3 |
On
an application for permission to issue a writ of possession under RSC
O.45 r.3(2), if the property consists of a house of which various
parts are sublet to, or in the occupation of, different persons, the
evidence in support should show the nature and length of the notice
which has been given to the various occupiers. Where the defendant or
any other persons are in actual possession of the premises of which
possession is sought, the evidence must contain the following
information:
| | |
| (1) |
whether the premises or any part of it is residential,
|
| (2) |
if so,
|
| |
| (a) |
what is the rateable value of the residential premises, and
|
| (b) |
whether it is let furnished or unfurnished and, if furnished, the
amount of furniture it contains, and
|
| | (3) |
any other matters that will assist the Master in deciding whether any
occupier is protected by the Rent Acts.
|
| | 12.2.4 |
Where
a party wishes to enforce a judgment or order expressed in a foreign
currency by the issue of a writ of fieri facias, the praecipe and
writ of fieri facias must be endorsed with the following certificate:
| | |
| |
"I/We
certify that the rate current in London for the purchase of (state
the unit of foreign currency in which the judgment is expressed) at
the close of business on (state the nearest preceding date to the
date of issue of the writ of fieri facias) was ( ) to the £
sterling and at this rate the sum of (state amount of the judgment debt in the foreign currency) amounts to £ ".
|
| | |
The
schedule to the writ of fieri facias should be amended;
| | |
| (1) |
showing the amount of the judgment or order in the foreign currency
at paragraph 1.
|
| (2) |
inserting a new paragraph 2. as follows:
|
| |
| "(2) |
Amount of the sterling equivalent as appears from the certificate endorsed on the praecipe for issue of the writ £ ".
|
| | (3) |
renumbering the remaining paragraphs accordingly.
|
| | |
The
writ of fieri facias wil then be issued for the sterling equivalent
of the judgment expressed in foreign currency as appears from the certificate.
|
| 12.2.5 |
County
Court judgments or orders to which Article 8(1) of the High Court and
County Courts Jurisdiction Order 1991 applies may be enforced in the
High Court, and since 26th April 1999, any County Court judgment for
over £600 may be transferred to the High Court for enforcement
by a High Court Enforcement Officer (except where it is a judgment
arising from a regulated agreement under the Consumer Credit Act).
|
| 12.2.6 |
The
party seeking enforcement should obtain from the appropriate county
court a certificate of the judgment of the county court in compliance
with CCR O. 22 r.8(1A) (in Schedule 2 to the CPR), setting out
details of the judgment or order to be enforced, sealed with the seal
of that court and dated and signed by an officer of that court and
stating on its face that it is granted for the purpose of enforcing
the judgment or order by execution against goods in the High Court.
Form N293A is a "Combined Certificate of Judgment and Request
for Writ of Fieri Facias" and should be used.
|
| 12.2.7 |
A
correctly completed form N293A together with a copy should be filed
in Room E15-E17 where the court officer will;
| | |
| (1) |
allocate a reference number,
|
| (2) |
date seal the Certificate and copy, returning the original to the
party and retaining the copy, and
|
| (3) |
enter the proceedings in a register kept for that purpose.
|
| | |
The certificate will be treated for enforcement purposes as a High Court
judgment and interest at the appropriate rate will run from the date
of the Certificate.
|
| 12.2.8 |
The
title of all subsequent documents shall be set out as follows:
| | |
| |
"IN
THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE
QUEEN'S
BENCH DIVISION
High
Court Claim No.
County
Court Claim No.
(Sent
from the [ ] County Court by Certificate dated (date))
Claimant
Defendant".
|
| | |
When
the writ of fieri facias is issued, the Certificate of judgment
retained by the party will be date-sealed by the court officer on the
bottom left hand corner and endorsed with either the named
Enforcement Officer or the District for Enforcement for which the
writ is directed.
|
| 12.2.9 |
The
Sheriffs Lodgement Centre at 20 – 21 Tooks Court, London EC4A 1LB
provides a service for arranging transfer up of county court
judgments. (A helpline is provided on 020 7205 2555)
|
| 12.2.10 |
It
is important to remember in these cases that although any application
for a stay of execution may be made to a Master in the High Court by application notice filed in accordance with Part 23, all other
applications for enforcement or other relief must be made to the
issuing county court. This practice is followed in the district
registries with such variations as circumstances require.
|
| 12.2.11 |
When
a writ of execution has been issued in the Royal Courts of Justice it
may then be delivered to the Sheriffs Lodgement Centre. Value Added
Tax is payable in addition to the High Court Enforcement Officer's
fee on the services for which the fee is payable, and must be paid at
the time of delivery of the writ. If the goods, chattels and
property to be seized in execution are not within Greater London, the
High Court Enforcement Officer will direct the writ to a High Court
Enforcement Officer who is authorised to act in the appropriate
district. Goods, which may not be seized in execution of a writ, are
set out in s.138(3A) of the Supreme Court Act 1981Acts as follows:
| | |
| (1) |
such tools, books, vehicles and other items of equipment as are
necessary to that person for use personally by him in his/her
employment, business or vocation,
|
| (2) |
such clothing, bedding, furniture, household equipment and provisions
as are necessary for satisfying the basic domestic needs of that
person and his/her family,
|
| (3) |
any money, bank notes, bills of exchange, promissory notes, bonds,
specialties or securities for money belonging to that person.
|
| | 12.2.12 |
When
first executing a writ of fieri facias the High Court Enforcement
Officer will deliver to the debtor or leave at each place where
execution is levied a notice of seizure in form No 55. This is
commonly known as "walking possession" and the notice
explains to the debtor the situation with regard to the goods seized
and what s/he then has to do.
|
| 12.2.13 |
After
execution of a writ of execution, the High Court Enforcement Officer
will endorse on the writ a statement of the manner in which s/he has
executed it and will send a copy of the statement to the party
issuing the writ.
|
|
| 12.3 | Interpleader proceedings (RSC O.17):
|
| |
| 12.3.1 |
Where
a person is under liability in respect of a debt or property and has
been, or expects to be claimed against by two or more persons
claiming the same debt or property, if the person under liability
does not dispute the debt or claim the property, s/he may apply to
the court for relief by way of interpleader, i.e. for the entitlement
of the persons claiming the same debt or property to be established
in separate proceedings between them.
|
| 12.3.2 |
Where
the High Court Enforcement Officer has seized goods in execution and
a person other than the person against whom the writ of execution was
issued wishes to claim the goods seized, s/he must give notice of
his/her claim to the High Court Enforcement Officer, including in
his/her notice a statement of his/her address which will be his/her
address for service. The High Court Enforcement Officer will then
give notice of that claim to the judgment creditor on whose behalf
the goods were seized, in form PF 23. The notice requires the judgment creditor to state whether s/he admits or disputes the
claim. The claimant must do so within 7 days of receipt of the High
Court Enforcement Officer's notice and may use form PF 24 to do so.
|
| 12.3.3 |
Where
the judgment creditor admits the claim, the High Court Enforcement
Officer will withdraw from possession of the goods and may apply
under RSC O.17 r.2(4) for an order to restrain a claim being brought
against him for having taken possession of the goods. Where the
claimant disputes the claim, the High Court Enforcement Officer may
apply for interpleader relief. An application for interpleader relief
if made in existing proceedings is made by an application in
accordance with Part 23, otherwise it is made by the issue of a Part
8 claim form.
|
| 12.3.4 |
The
Master may deal with the claims summarily, or may direct an issue to
be tried between the parties in dispute (see RSC O.17 r.5) or make
such other order as is appropriate.
|
|
| 12.4 |
Examination of judgment debtor (Part 71):
|
| |
| 12.4.1 |
Where
a person ("the judgment creditor") has obtained a judgment
or order for payment of a sum of money against a person ("the judgment debtor"), the judgment creditor may apply for an order
requiring the judgment debtor to attend to be orally examined
concerning his assets and means. If the judgment debtor is a company or corporation, the court will order a named officer of the company or corporation to attend for examination. In the case of a judgment
or order which is not for payment of a sum of money, the court may
make an order for the attendance of the party liable for his
examination on such questions as may be specified in the order.
|
| 12.4.2 |
An
application for an order under Part 71 should be made in accordance
with Part 23 without notice to any other party. The application must
be supported by evidence giving details of the judgment or order,
including the amount still owing, and showing that the judgment
creditor is entitled to enforce the judgment or order. Where the judgment debtor is a company or corporation the evidence must give
details of the officer to be examined. Form PF 98 may be used as a
precedent for the evidence in support. Where a judgment creditor has
obtained judgments in several different proceedings against the same judgment debtor, only one application need be made, setting out in
the body of the application details of all the judgments on which
examination is sought.
|
| 12.4.3 |
The
examination will take place before a Master, Registrar, District
Judge or nominated officer, as may be ordered, and will normally be
at the court where the least expense will be incurred, usually the
county court for the area where the judgment debtor lives. If a
different court is requested by the applicant the reason why should
be given in the application notice.
|
| 12.4.4 |
The application notice/evidence should be filed in the Masters' Support
Unit Room E16 for consideration by a Master who will, if satisfied,
make the order sought. Where the examination is to take place in a
county court, the judgment creditor should lodge a copy of the order
with the county court and obtain an appointment for the examination.
If the examination is to take place in the Royal Courts of Justice,
the order should be taken to Room E17 where the appointment will be
endorsed on the order. In the Central Office the officers are
nominated at the discretion of the Senior Master and their names may
be obtained from Room E17.
|
| 12.4.5 |
The
order (endorsed with the penal notice as set out in paragraph 9.1 of
the Part 40B Practice Direction) together with details of the
appointment must be served personally on the judgment debtor or on
the officer of the judgment debtor company or corporation to be
examined. A judgment debtor should be offered his conduct money, i.e.
expenses of travelling to and from the examination and of attending
to give evidence.
|
| 12.4.6 |
The officer conducting the examination will take down, or arrange to have
taken down in writing the judgment debtor's statement. The officer will read the statement to the judgment debtor and will ask him or
her to sign it. If he or she refuses to do so the officer will sign
the statement. If the judgment debtor refuses to answer any question
or if any other difficulties arise, the matter will be referred to
the Interim Applications Judge in Court 37.
|
|
| 12.5 | Third
Party Debt Order proceedings (CPR Part 72):
|
| |
| 12.5.1 |
Where
a judgment creditor has obtained a judgment or order for payment of a
sum of money against a judgment debtor, and another person ("the Third Party ") is indebted to the judgment debtor, the judgment
creditor may apply to the Master for an order that the Third Party pays to the judgment creditor the amount of the debt due to the judgment debtor, or sufficient of it to satisfy the judgment debt.
|
| 12.5.2 |
The
application should be made by filing an application notice in
Practice Form N349, verified by a statement of truth, but the application notice need not be served on the judgment debtor. The
application will normally be dealt with without a hearing and must be
supported by evidence as set out in CPR 72 Practice Direction 1.2.
If the Master is satisfied that such an order is appropriate, s/he
will make an interim order in form N84 specifying the debt attached
and appointing a time for the Third Party and the judgment debtor to
attend and show cause why the order should not be made final.
|
| 12.5.3 |
The Third Party Debt Order to show cause must be served on the Third
Party, and on the judgment debtor, in accordance with CPR 72.5. Where
the Third Party or the judgment debtor fails to attend the hearing or
attends but does not dispute the debt, the Master may make a final Third Party Debt Order against the Third Party under CPR 72.8 in form
N85. The final order may be enforced in the same manner as any other
order for the payment of money. Where the Third Party or the judgment debtor disputes the debt, the Master may dispose of the matter as set
out in CPR 72.8.
|
| 12.5.4 |
Where
the judgment creditor seeks to enforce a judgment expressed in a
foreign currency by Third Party Debt Order proceedings, the evidence
in support of the application must contain words to the following
effect:
| | |
| |
"The
rate current in London for the purchase of (state the unit of foreign
currency in which the judgment is expressed) at the close of business
on (state the nearest preceding date to the date of verifying the
evidence) was ( ) to the £ sterling, and at this rate the sum
of (state the amount of the judgment debt in the foreign currency)
amounts to £…… I have obtained this information from (state
source) and believe it to be true."
|
|
|
| 12.6 | Charging
Orders (CPR Part 73):
|
| |
| 12.6.1 |
A judgment creditor may apply for a charging order on the property or
assets of the judgment debtor, which will have the effect of
providing him with security over the property of the judgment debtor.
The High Court has jurisdiction to impose a charging order in the
following cases:
| | |
| (1) |
where the property is a fund lodged in the High Court,
| | (2) |
where the order to be enforced is a maintenance order of the High
Court, and
| | (3) |
where the judgment or order is made in the High Court and exceeds
£5000.
|
| | |
The
property and assets of the judgment debtor on which a charge may be
imposed by a charging order are specified by s.2 of the Charging
Orders Act 1979.
|
| 12.6.2 |
An
interim charging order imposing a charge on land will be drawn in
respect of the judgment debtors interest in the land and not the land itself, unless the court orders otherwise. If an interim charging
order is made on stocks or shares in more than one company, a
separate order must be drawn in respect of each company. A judgment
creditor may apply in a single application notice for charging orders
over more than one asset, but if the court makes charging orders over
more than one asset, there will be separate orders relating to each
asset. If the judgment debt is expressed in a foreign currency, the
evidence in support of any application for a charging order should
contain a similar provision to that set out in paragraph 12.5.4
above.
|
| 12.6.3 |
The
application for a charging order is made to a Master and should be
made in Practice Form N379 if the application relates to land, or
N380 if the application relates to securities. The application is
made without being served and will normally be dealt with without a
hearing. If the Master is satisfied that such an order is
appropriate, s/he will make an order in form N86 appointing a time
for the judgment debtor to attend and show cause why the order should
not be made absolute.
|
| 12.6.4 |
The
interim order and the application notice should be served in
accordance with CPR 73.5, or otherwise as directed by the Master.
After further consideration at the hearing the Master will either
make the order Final (with or without modifications) as in form N87,
or discharge it. Where the order is discharged or varied, the order
of discharge must be served in accordance with CPR 73.9(3).
|
| 12.6.5 |
CPR 73.7 deals with the effects of a charging order on funds in
court, which includes securities held in court.
|
| 12.6.6 |
Although the court may make a charging order in a foreign currency,
to facilitate enforcement it is usually preferable for it to be
expressed in sterling. Thus if the foreign debt is in a foreign
currency the evidence in support of the application should contain
the sterling equivalent and request the charging order to be made in
sterling. (See paragraph 12.6.2 above).
| | |
Enforcement
of Charging Order
|
| 12.6.6 |
Proceedings for the enforcement of a charging order by sale of the
property charged must be begun by a Part 8 Claim Form issued out of
the Chancery Division of the High Court or a Chancery district
registry unless the High Court has no jurisdiction, in which case
application should be made to the appropriate County Court. (RSC
O.50 r.9A). The County Court's limit at present is when the amount
owing does not exceed £30,000.
|
|
| 12.7 | Receivers;
equitable execution (CPR Part 69):
|
| |
| 12.7.1 |
Equitable
execution is a process which enables a judgment creditor to obtain
payment of the judgment debt where the interest of the judgment debtor in property cannot be seized or reached by ordinary execution.
|
| 12.7.2 |
An
application for appointment of a receiver by way of equitable
execution may be made to a Master, who also has jurisdiction to grant
an injunction if, and only so far as, the injunction is ancillary or
incidental to the order. The procedure follows that set out in RSC
O.30 rr.1 to 6, and the application should be made in accordance with
Part 23 and the Part 23 Practice Direction as described in the
following paragraphs.
|
| 12.7.3 |
If
the judgment creditor seeks an injunction (as in 11.7.2 above) s/he
should file his/her application notice based on form No. 82 but
setting out in addition the injunction sought, together with a
witness statement or affidavit in support stating:
| | |
| (1) |
the date and particulars of the judgment, and that it remains wholly
unsatisfied, or to what extent it remains unsatisfied,
|
| (2) |
the particulars and result of any execution which has been issued,
and the nature of the High Court Enforcement Officer's return (if
any),
|
| (3) |
that the judgment debtor has no property which can be taken by the ordinary process of execution, (ifs/he has, give reasons showing that
legal execution would be futile),
|
| (4) |
particulars of the property in respect of which it is proposed to
appoint a receiver,
|
| (5) |
the name and address of the receiver proposed to be appointed, and
that in the deponent's judgments/he is a fit and proper person to
be appointed receiver, and
|
| (6) |
that the judgment debtor is in financial difficulties [that the
immediate appointment of a receiver without the delay of giving
security is of great importance] and that the deponent believes that
the judgment debtor may assign or dispose of his/her estate or
interest in (give details of property) unless restrained from doing
so by the order and injunction of the court.
|
| | 12.7.4 |
The judgment creditor need not give notice of this application which will
normally be dealt with without a hearing. If the Master is satisfied
with the evidence s/he will make an order in form No. 83 for a
hearing to take place in respect of the application for the
appointment of the receiver and granting an injunction meanwhile.
|
| 12.7.5 |
If
the judgment creditor does not seek an injunction, the application
notice should be filed and served together with the evidence in
support (as in paragraph 11.7.3 above but without paragraph (6)).
|
| 12.7.6 |
At
the hearing of the application to appoint the receiver, the Master
will, if s/he thinks fit, make an order in form No. 84. A copy of the
order appointing the receiver shall be served by the judgment
creditor on the receiver and all other parties to the proceedings.
|
| 12.7.7 |
Where
a receiver has been ordered to give security under RSC O.30 r.2, the judgment creditor should obtain an appointment before the Master who
made the order appointing the receiver, to settle the form and amount
of the security. Unless otherwise ordered, the security will be in
the form of a guarantee. The judgment creditor should have prepared a
draft form of guarantee for the Master to approve at the appointment.
Form PF 30CH may be used as a precedent for the guarantee.
|
| 12.7.8 |
RSC
O.30 r.3 deals with the remuneration of the receiver which may either
be assessed by the Master or referred to a costs judge. RSC O.30 r.5
contains the provisions for submitting the receiver's accounts.
|
|
| 12.8 | Committals, etc. (RSC O.52)
|
| |
| 12.8.1 |
The
court has power to punish contempt of court by an order of committal
to prison or by other means. These may be by ordering the payment of
a fine, by the issue of a writ of sequestration, or by making a
hospital or guardianship order under certain provisions of the Mental
Health Act 1983. Committal applications under RSC O.52 r.4 are always
dealt with by a High Court Judge. The following provisions apply to
applications made under RSC O.52 r.4.
|
| 12.8.2 |
The
application should be made in existing proceedings by filing an application notice. If not in existing proceedings, a Part 8 Claim
Form should be issued (see paragraphs 2.1 and 2.2 of the practice
direction -- Committal Applications). The Claim Form or application
notice must contain a prominent notice stating the possible
consequences of the court making a committal order. The notice is
annexed at the end of the practice direction.
|
| 12.8.3 |
Evidence in support of a committal application must be by affidavit
and, together with the Part 8 Claim Form or application notice, must
be served personally on the person sought to be committed giving 14
days notice unless otherwise directed by the court (paragraph 4.2 of
the practice direction). A date for the hearing must be obtained from
the Listing Office, Room WG8 and endorsed on or served with the Claim
Form or application notice.
|
| 12.8.4 |
Paragraphs
2.5, 2.6 and 3.1 to 3.4 of the Practice Direction deal with the
content of the evidence, and serving and filing, and paragraph 4
deals with the hearing date and management of the proceedings.
|
| 12.8.5 |
Committal proceedings will normally be heard in public, but see RSC O.52 r.6
which sets out certain types of cases which may be heard in private
(although brief details of the case must be read out in public) and
see paragraph 9 of the Practice Direction.
|
| 12.8.6 |
Where
the court makes a finding of contempt, details of the contempt and of
the order or undertaking breached (where appropriate) must be set out
in the order. The term of any period of committal must be stated in
the order and must not exceed two years. A fine must be expressed as
payable to Her Majesty the Queen and the order must state the amount
of the fine and the date and time within which it must be paid. A
contemnor and his solicitors will be notified separately as to how
the fine should be paid. A precedent of the order is in form No. 85
and will normally be drawn by the court.
|
| 12.8.7 |
When
an order for committal to prison is made, the court will issue a warrant to the Tipstaff authorising him to convey the contemnor to
the appropriate prison. A copy of the order should be served on the
prison governor and the Official Solicitor. RSC O.52 r.8 deals with
the discharge of a person committed.
|
|
| 12.9 | Execution
against property of Foreign or Commonwealth States:
|
| |
| 12.9.1 |
In
cases where judgment has been obtained against a foreign or
Commonwealth State and it is sought to execute the judgment by a writ
of fieri facias, a charging order or a Third Party Debt Order, the
following provisions apply:
| | |
| (1) |
Before the writ of fieri facias is issued, the Master must be
informed in writing and his/her direction sought. In cases where an
application is to be made for a charging order to show cause or a Third Party to show cause, the evidence in support of the application
must include a statement that the execution sought is against a
foreign or Commonwealth State.
| | (2) |
The Master, having been so informed will, as soon as practicable,
inform the Foreign and Commonwealth Office ("FCO") of the
application and will not permit the issue of a writ of fieri facias,
nor grant an order to show cause until the FCO has been so informed.
The Protocol Division of the Head of Diplomatic Missions and
International Organisations Unit of the FCO may be contacted by
telephone on 020 7008 0991 or by Fax on 020 7008 0978.
| | (3) |
Having regard to all the circumstances of the case, the Master may
postpone the decision whether to issue the writ or grant the order to
show cause for so long as s/he considers reasonable for the purpose
of enabling the FCO to furnish further information relevant to
his/her decision, but not for longer than 3 days from the time of
his/her contacting the FCO. In the event that no further information
is received from the FCO within 24 hours of its being informed, then
the writ of fieri facias may be issued or the order to show cause may
be sealed without further delay.
|
|
|
| 12.10 | Recovery
of enforcement costs:
|
| |
| 12.10.1 |
Subsection
(3) of section 15 of the Courts and Legal Services Act 1990Acts enables a
person taking steps to enforce a money judgment in the High Court to
recover the costs of any previous attempt to enforce that judgment.
Subsection (4) of section 15 excludes costs that the court considers
to have been unreasonably incurred.
|
| 12.10.2 |
The
application for an enforcement costs order is made to a Master and
should be made in accordance with Part 23 but the application notice need not be served on the judgment debtor. The application will
normally be dealt with without a hearing and must be supported by
evidence substantially as set out in form PF 205. The deponent should
exhibit sufficient vouchers, receipts or other documents as are
reasonably necessary to verify the amount of the costs of previous
attempts to enforce the judgment.
|
| 12.10.3 |
If
the Master is satisfied that such an order is appropriate, s/he will
make an order for payment of the amount of such costs ass/he
considers may be recoverable under subsection (3) of section 15. If
the amount of such costs is less than that claimed by the judgment
creditor, the Master may either disallow the balance or give
directions for a detailed assessment or other determination of the
balance. If after assessment or other determination it appears that
the judgment creditor is entitled to further costs beyond those
originally allowed, s/he may issue a further writ of fieri facias or
take other lawful steps to enforce those costs. Interest on the costs runs either from the date the Master made the enforcement costs order
or from the date of the costs certificate.
|
|
| 12.11 | Enforcement
of Magistrates' Courts' orders:
|
| |
| 12.11.1 |
The
Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s.87 provides that payment of a sum
ordered to be paid on a conviction of a magistrates' court may be
enforced by the High Court or a county court (otherwise than by the
issue of a writ of fieri facias or other process against goods or by
imprisonment or attachment of earnings) as if the sum were due to the
clerk of the magistrates' court under a judgment of the High Court
or county court, as the case may be.
|
| 12.11.2 |
In
the Central Office, the application is made to a Master and should be
made in accordance with Part 23. Where enforcement is sought by a Third Party Debt Order or charging order to show cause, the
application will normally be dealt with without a hearing. Otherwise
the application notice and evidence in support should be served on
the defendant.
|
| 12.11.3 |
The
application must be supported by a witness statement or affidavit in
a form appropriate to the type of execution sought and must have
exhibited to it the authority of the magistrates' court to take the proceedings which will recite the conviction, the amount outstanding
and the nature of the proceedings authorised to be taken (Magistrates
Courts Forms Rules 1981, Form 63).
|
| 12.11.4 |
The application notice and evidence in support together with an
additional copy of the exhibit should be filed in Room E15 where it
will be assigned a reference number from the register kept for that
purpose. The Master according to the type of enforcement sought will
then deal with the matter.
|
| 12.11.5 |
This
practice will also be followed in the District Registries with such
variations as circumstances may render necessary.
|
|
| 12.12 | Enforcement of Foreign Judgments and Enforcement of High Court
Judgments Abroad
|
| |
| 12.12.1 |
CPR 74 deals with enforcement of judgments in different jurisdictions. Section 1 covers enforcement in England & Wales
of judgments of foreign courts.
|
| 12.12.2 |
If a foreign court is not a party to an agreement with this country
on mutual recognition and enforcement of judgments, then a fresh
action will need to be brought based on that foreign judgment. Such
an action can usually be made by a Part 8 claim.
|
| 12.12.3 |
Section 1 of the rule covers enforcement of judgments of foreign
courts covered by the Administration of Justice Act 1933 (“the 1933
Act”), the Foreign Judgments (Reciprocal Enforcement) Act 1933
(“the 1933 Act”), the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982Acts
(“the 1982 Act”) and the Council Regulation (EC) No. 44/2001 of
22nd December 2000 (“the Judgments Regulation”).
|
| 12.12.4 |
A list of the countries that are covered by each of the various Acts and the Judgments Regulation is set out in Her Majesty's Court
Service ‘Notes for Guidance' on the above Acts and Regulation,
which can be obtained from the Judgments & Orders Section of the
Action Department of the Central Office (Room E17). This also
contains the standard forms used and sets out the procedure for
applications for registration.
| | |
Reciprocal
enforcement; the Administration of Justice Act 1920Acts the Foreign
Judgments (Reciprocal Enforcement) Act 1933, the Civil Jurisdiction
and Judgments Act 1982 and the Judgments Regulation.
|
| 12.12.5 |
CPR
74.4 sets out how an application for registration of a foreign
judgment in the High Court under the 1920, 1933 or 1982 Acts under
the Judgments Regulation may be made. The application should be made
without notice being served on any other party, but the Master may
direct that a Part 8 Claim Form should be issued and served.
|
| 12.12.6 |
CPR
74.4 (2)-(6) sets out what the evidence in support of the application
should contain or have exhibited to it. The foreign judgment will
be registered in the foreign currency in which it is expressed and
must not be converted into Sterling in the evidence in support. When
it comes to enforcing the foreign judgment, the amount should then be
converted in accordance with the instructions set out above in
paragraph 11 in respect of the type of enforcement sought.
|
| 12.12.7 |
The
order giving permission to register the judgment must be drawn up by,
or on behalf of the judgment creditor and will be entered in the Register of Judgments kept in the Action Department Room E17 of the
Central Office for that purpose. The order will usually contain a
direction that the costs of and caused by the application and the
registration be assessed and added to the judgment as registered. The
Order for registration of the judgment must state the matters set out
in CPR 74.6 (3) including the right of the judgment debtor to apply,
and the time within which s/he may do so, to have the registration
set aside. The notice must be served on the judgment debtor in
accordance with CPR 74.6 (1).
|
| 12.12.8 |
An
application to set aside the registration of a judgment under CPR
74.7 (1) must be made in accordance with Part 23 and be supported by
a witness statement or affidavit.
|
| 12.12.9 |
Section 2 of CPR 74 covers enforcement in foreign countries of
judgments of the High Court and County Court of England & Wales.
A judgment creditor who wishes to enforce such a judgment abroad must
apply for a certified copy of the judgment.
|
| 12.12.10 |
Section 3 of CPR 74 deals with enforcement of UK Judgments in other
parts of the UK. A person who wishes to enforce a judgment of the
High Court or County Court of England & Wales in another part of
the UK may apply for a certified copy of the judgment.
|
| 12.12.11 |
An
application for a certified copy of a judgment entered in the High
Court may be made without notice and must be supported by evidence,
in accordance with CPR 74.13 for enforcement of High Court and County
judgments in foreign countries, and in accordance with CPR 74.17or 18
for enforcement of High Court and County judgments in other parts of
the UK. The certified copy will be endorsed with a certificate signed by the Master. The forms of certificate are included in the
‘Notes for Guidance' referred to in paragraph 11.12.4 above.
Where the application was made under s. 10 of the Foreign Judgments
(Reciprocal Enforcement) Act 1933, an additional certificate will be
issued and signed by the Master [as in form PF 155.] Judgment
creditors who intend to seek enforcement abroad should ensure that
their judgment is endorsed as follows:
| | |
| |
"This
judgment carries interest from (date) at the rate of 8% per annum in
accordance with the provisions of the Judgments Act 1838Acts".
|
|
| 12.12.12 |
An application may also be made for registration in the High Court of
a judgment given by a court in another part of the UK.
|
| 12.12.13 |
The certificate must be filed for registration in Room E15 – E17 in
the Action Department within 6 months from the date of its issue.
Under paragraph 9 of schedule 6 to the Act of 1982 an application may
be made to stay the enforcement of the certificate. The application
may be made without notice being served on any other party supported
by a witness statement or affidavit stating that the applicant is
entitled and intends to apply to the judgment court to set aside or
stay the judgment.
| | |
Applications
under s.18 of the Act of 1982; judgment containing non-money
provisions: The procedure is set out in CPR 74.16(3).
|
| 12.12.14 |
The certificates will be entered in the register of certificates in
respect of judgments ordered to be registered under CPR 74 PD 3 kept
in the Central Office for that purpose.
| | |
Enforcement
of European Community judgments
|
| 12.12.15 |
Section 4 of CPR deals with enforcement of European Community
judgments in England and Wales, that is, judgments not of the
national courts of Member States but rather the judgments of the
courts and institutes of the community itself.
|
| 12.12.16 |
CPR
74.19 An application for registration may be made without notice
being served on any other party and must be supported by written
evidence containing or having exhibited to it the matters referred to
in CPR 74.21 (1).
|
| 12.12.17 |
The
order for registration must contain the information and exhibit the
documents required by CPR 74.22. The order for registration will be
entered in the register of the Judgments and Orders kept in the
Action Department Room E17, Central Office for that purpose. The registration order must be served on every person against whom
judgment was given.
|
| 12.12.18 |
An
application to vary or cancel a registration under the provisions of
CPR 74.23 shall be made by application notice in accordance with Part
23, supported by written evidence, and must be made within 28 days of
service of the registration order.
| | |
Enforcement
of recommendations etc. under the Merchant Shipping (Liner
Conferences) Act 1982
|
| 12.12.19 |
Applications
under s. 9 of the Act of 1982 for registration of a recommendation, determination or award, are dealt with by a Commercial Judge and
shall be made by the issue of a Part 8 Claim Form. The application
should be supported by evidence in accordance with CPR 74 PD 12.
|
| 12.12.20 |
The
order giving permission to register the recommendation, determination or award must be drawn up by or on behalf of the party making the
application, and entered in the register of the recommendations, determinations and awards ordered to be registered under s. 9 of the Act of 1982, directed by the Senior Master to be kept in the Admiralty and Commercial Registry.
| | |
Regulation
(EC) No. 805/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21
April 2004 (“the European Enforcement Order”)
|
| 12.12.21 |
The European Enforcement Order (EEO) creates a simplified method of
enforcement for uncontested claims throughout the EU member states
(except Denmark). Details of the procedure are contained in Section V of Part 74.
|
| 12.12.22 |
An application for an EEO certificate must be made
by Form N219 or N219A depending upon whether the Judgment was by
agreement/admission/settlement or in default of defence or objection.
The application may be made without notice and will be dealt with
without a hearing, unless the Master orders a hearing.
|
| 12.12.23 |
An application under Article 6(2) of the EEO Regulation for a certificate indicating the lack or limitation of enforceability of an
EEO certificate must be made to the court of origin by application in
accordance with Part 23.
|
| 12.12.24 |
An application under Article 10 of the EEO Regulation for
rectification or withdrawal of an EEO certificate must be made to the court of origin and may be made by application in accordance with
Part 23.
| | 12.12.25 |
A
person seeking to enforce an EEO in England and Wales must lodge
at the court in which enforcement proceedings are to be
brought the documents required
by Article 20 of the EEO Regulation.
|
| 12.12.26 |
Where an EEO certificate has
been lodged and the judgment debtor applies to stay or limit the
enforcement proceedings under Article 23 of the EEO Regulation,
such application must be made by application in accordance with
Part 23 to the court in which the EEO is being enforced.
|
| 12.12.27 |
An application under Article 21 of the EEO Regulation that the
court should refuse to enforce an EEO must be made by application
in accordance with Part 23 to the court in which the EEO is being
enforced.
|
|