|
SECTION 1 1 |
|
1.1 |
The Work of the SCCO |
| |
| (a) |
The Supreme Court Costs Office (SCCO) is a distinct part of the High Court,
separate from the Queens Bench Division, Chancery Division and Family Division. It has
two ranks of judicial officer: Costs Judges (also known as Taxing Masters and as Masters of
the SCCO) and costs officers (senior civil servants from whose decisions appeals lie as of
right to a Costs Judge).
|
| (b) |
The primary function of the SCCO is the assessment of costs which are
recoverable from a litigant by another litigant or by a lawyer. In the past, assessments (then
called "taxations") were conducted by specialist Judges appointed to each court. In 1842
the office of Taxing Master was created and Taxing Masters were appointed to each Division
of the High Court. The Supreme Court Taxing Office was originally one of the Departments
which made up the Central Office. At the start of the 20
th
century it took over the work of
the Chancery Taxing Masters. In 1999 the Civil Procedure Rules ("CPR") adopted the term
"detailed assessment" in place of "taxation" at which time the SCCO was created. It now
has jurisdiction to assess costs awarded by any Judge of the Court of Appeal, High Court or
County Court. Since 2000 it has had the jurisdiction to assess orders for costs made in the
Family Division of the High Court and in the Principal Registry.
|
| (c) |
Regional Costs Judges
Regional Costs Judges have been appointed on all circuits outside London. They are District
Judges who have been appointed to hear detailed assessment of bills of costs that fall within
the criteria of the scheme at a venue which is convenient to the parties and their legal
representatives.
| | | The criteria for a detailed assessment to be referred to a Regional Costs Judge, rather than the
local District Judge, are as follows: the time estimate for the detailed assessment exceeds
one day; and/or the sum claimed exceeds £50,000; and/or complex arguments on points of
21
law, or an issue affecting a group of similar cases, are identified in the points of dispute or the
reply or are referred to in argument at a detailed assessment hearing.
| | | Once a request for detailed assessment in Form N258 has been filed at court the bill will be
referred to a District Judge who will consider whether it falls within the criteria for reference
to a Regional Costs Judge. If it does, the bill will be referred to the appropriate Regional
Costs Judge who will then decide whether to accept it and will give any directions required,
including directions as to listing.
| | | If a party wishes to make submissions as to whether any particular detailed assessment fulfils
the criteria for reference to a Regional Costs Judge, or as to the most convenient court for any
hearing before a Regional Costs Judge, they should first consult the other parties or their legal
representatives before making submissions to the court. It is helpful if such submissions are
filed with the court when the request for detailed assessment is lodged. If possible the
parties should attempt to agree the reference to the Regional Costs Judge, any directions and
the most convenient venue.
| | | A list of the names and court addresses of the District Judges who were appointed Regional
Costs Judges in 2005 is set out on pages 12 and 13, above.
|
|
|
1.2 |
Representation |
| |
| (a) |
Solicitors
| | | In most cases parties will be represented by the solicitors who have acted for them in the
litigation in which the order for costs has been made. The name, address, telephone and fax
numbers and reference of each such solicitor is set out on the Statement of Parties which is
lodged when a request for a detailed assessment hearing is made (see further, Section 8,
below).
| | | Where proceedings are brought by claim form under Part III of the Solicitors Act 1974Acts, the
name and other details of each party's solicitor are set out in the claim form or in the
acknowledgment of service, as the case may be.
Solicitors remain on the record of the court until they obtain an order for their removal, or
until another firm or the litigant in person files and serves a notice of acting. Notices of
acting should be filed in the SCCO and also in the court office of the court in which the
relevant order for costs was made if proceedings are still continuing in that court.
| | | The firm on the record may be represented by a fee earner, for example, a partner, an
assistant solicitor, a legal executive, a trainee solicitor or a paralegal or other clerk employed
by the firm. Alternatively, firms outside London sometimes instruct a firm of solicitors in
London to act on their behalf as an agent at any hearing.
|
| (b) |
Bankrupt Party
| | | A bankrupt has no right to be heard unless an order under Section 303 of the Insolvency Act
1986 has been made. It is normally for the trustee in bankruptcy to decide what steps to
take on behalf of the bankrupt's estate in relation to any proceedings in the SCCO.
|
| (c) |
Company
| | | Under the CPR, companies are not required to act by a solicitor when starting proceedings or
defending them. Thus, they may act by any duly authorised agent. Where a document is to
be verified on behalf of a company a statement of truth as to that document may be signed by
any person holding a senior position in the company. However, once a matter proceeds to a
hearing, the company, by its officers or employees or otherwise, has no personal right of
audience. CPR 39.6 permits the representation of a company "at trial" by an employee but
this is not as of right; the rule states that the person wishing to speak for the company must
obtain the court's permission. The Practice Direction to that rule sets out the information to
be given to the court in such circumstances, states that such permission should be sought in
advance and states that such permission may be obtained informally and without notice to the
other parties. Although CPR 39.6 concerns representation at trial, the Practice Direction
provisions concern representations at any hearing.
|
| (d) |
Costs draftsmen
At present independent costs draftsmen have no rights of audience as such but, by
concession, are treated as if they are in the employ of the firm of solicitors instructing them.
They have no rights of audience on behalf of a litigant in person (but see McKenzie Friend
below). It has been proposed that the Association of Law Costs Draftsmen should be
authorised to grant rights of audience and rights to conduct litigation to certain of its
members when participating in detailed assessments.
| | | |
| (e) |
Patent agents, trademark agents and claims consultants
| | | In any patent action conducted by a patent agent, the patent agent may have a right to appear.
Similar rights have now been granted to trademark agents in respect of trademark cases. In
certain cases (such as arbitrations and planning matters) surveyors and other persons acting as
claims consultants who have conducted the proceedings may be permitted to appear.
|
| (f) |
Counsel and counsel's clerks
| | | Counsel properly briefed by solicitors or by the litigant have full rights of audience.
However, if they appear on their own behalf without a brief they are not entitled to a fee.
Counsel's clerks attending as such do not have any right of audience. However, in an
exceptional case, counsel's clerk may be allowed a hearing on behalf of counsel if counsel so
requests in writing and if the Costs Judge or costs officer so allows.
|
| (g) |
McKenzie Friend
| | | As a general rule, a litigant in person will be allowed to receive the assistance of a friend at
the hearing to give advice and to take notes (but not to act as advocate). However, in a
particular case, the court may refuse to allow such assistance to be given, or to be continued,
if there are strong and compelling reasons for believing that such assistance will impede the
efficient administration of justice.
|
|
|
1.3 |
Sitting Master |
| |
Costs Judges act from time to time on a rota basis as Sitting Master to hear applications, in
detailed assessment proceedings which have not been assigned to a particular Costs Judge or
24
costs officer, to hear applications under the Solicitors Act 1974Acts and to deal with enquiries
relating to practice and law arising out of assessments. Such enquiries may be made
indirectly, via his clerk, or, in the case of Judges of the Supreme Court or other courts
throughout the country, directly.
|
|
1.4 |
Office hours |
| |
| (a) |
In common with other civil courts the SCCO is open from 10 am until 4.30 pm
from Mondays to Fridays. It is closed on public holidays and on the Tuesday after Easter
Monday.
|
| (b) |
During the month of August it is not possible to issue or file documents in the
SCCO after 2.30 pm. However cases may still be listed for hearing throughout the day and
therefore the office remains open to lawyers, litigants and the public wishing to attend such
hearings.
|
|
|
1.5 |
SCCO Support Sections |
| |
Once proceedings have been commenced in the SCCO further work done in preparation for
hearings is dealt with by the clerks of the Costs Judges Section for hearings before a Master
and by clerks of the Costs Officers Section for hearings before a costs officer. When an
assessment has been completed and the appropriate fees paid these Sections will also deal
with the issue of the final costs certificates. The clerks in these Sections deal with
appointments, correspondence and telephone enquiries. They do not give legal advice to
parties. However, assistance and guidance will be given in appropriate circumstances as to
general office practice.
Assistance and guidance on technical matters which are complex and difficult may be
referred to the Principal Costs Officer or to a designated senior clerk who will endeavour to
help, possibly after consultation with the Costs Judge or costs officer to whom the case has
been allocated.
|
|
1.6 |
The SCCO File |
| |
On receiving the appropriate documents and court fees in respect of each application or
request the court clerks will open a file and allocate to it a distinct file number.
Subsequently further documents may be added to that file, eg, correspondence, witness
statements, notes of hearings and the orders made thereon. Unless the court otherwise
orders, any party to the proceedings is entitled, without permission, to obtain a copy of any
document filed in the SCCO in respect of those proceedings if he pays any prescribed fee and
files a written request for the document. Persons other than parties have much more limited
rights of obtaining documents from the court file (CPR 5.4).
|
|
1.7 |
Referrals to the RCJ Citizens Advice Bureau |
| |
| (a) |
The Citizens Advice Bureau is able to give general legal advice to litigants in
person and, for this purpose, maintains an office in the Royal Courts of Justice near the Main
Hall.
|
| (b) |
The Bureau operates on a "first come first served" basis. Clients will be seen
first by a receptionist who will assess their eligibility for assistance by the Bureau. If they
are eligible and the advice and assistance sought falls within the Bureau's remit they will be
referred to a lawyer who will endeavour to provide the advice or assistance sought.
Problems which can be resolved quickly will normally be dealt with there and then. If
matters need more time, for example those involving a difficult point of law or procedure, or
those requiring more information, research or the drafting of documents, the client will be
asked to come back and an appointment made.
|
| (c) |
Further information about the RCJ Citizens Advice Bureau and its referral
scheme can be obtained from the SCCO Support Sections.
|
|
|
1.8 |
Contacting the SCCO by Letter or Fax |
| |
| (a) |
Although, during office hours, applications and other documents may be
delivered by hand to the Costs Office, in practice most are delivered by letter or by fax. All
such documentation should be sent with a covering letter stating any SCCO references
relevant to the documentation. If a fee is payable the documentation should include a
cheque or bankers draft made in favour of HM Paymaster General or HMPG. Parties who
26
wish to pay court fees in cash must hand deliver the payment to Room E01 in the Royal
Courts of Justice.
|
| (b) |
Letters and documentation may be sent by post to:
The Court Manager
Supreme Court Costs Office
Cliffords Inn
Fetter Lane
London EC4A 1DQ
| | | Or by document exchange (DX) to DX 44454 Strand.
|
| (c) |
In an emergency urgent documents may be sent to the Costs Office by fax on
number 020 7947 6247 or 020 7947 6344. If the fax relates to a hearing, the date and time
of the hearing should be prominently displayed as well as the relevant SCCO reference
number. Examples of urgent documents it is appropriate to send by fax are: documents
required by the court at short notice before the hearing and letters informing the court of a
settlement which obviates the need for some or all parties to attend a hearing. A fax should
not be used to send letters or documents of a routine or non urgent nature, bills of costs,
papers supporting bills or skeleton arguments.
|
| (d) |
Where a document is filed by fax, the party filing it is not required in addition
to send to the SCCO any further copy of that document, eg by post or document exchange.
Documents sent by fax are not to be regarded as filed at court unless and until they are
delivered by the court's fax machine. If a fax is delivered after 4 pm, or at any time on a
day when the court office is closed, it will be treated as filed on the next day the court office
is open.
|
|
|
1.9 |
Contacting the SCCO by Telephone |
| |
| (a) |
The SCCO can be contacted via the telephone numbers set out in the List of
Costs Judges and Costs Officers (see page 11, above) or via the switchboard at the Royal
27
Courts of Justice, the number of which is 020 7947 6000. Also once a file has been opened
and the SCCO has entered into correspondence thereon the SCCO notepaper and
compliments slips will show the telephone number of the relevant clerk. Parties should use
this number when contact by letter or fax is not possible or not appropriate.
|
| (b) |
In some cases the hearing of a detailed assessment may be conducted by
telephone. If it is a hearing at which more than one party may be represented, the court will
give directions as to who must arrange the conference call and the Costs Office number
which should be used on that call. Most telephone hearings concern cases in which only
one party wishes to attend. In those cases the court will give directions stating the Costs
Office telephone number to be used, the date and time of the appointment and stating whether
it should be by way of a conference call or an ordinary telephone call.
|
|
|
1.10 |
SCCO Page on the Court Service Website |
| |
The SCCO page on the Court Service Website comprises a miscellany of information
including the text of various guides and guideline figures published by the SCCO and the text
of the Civil Procedure Rules and Practice Directions on Costs and summaries of recent costs
appeals which contain important points of principle. The address of the SCCO page is
www.hmcourts-service.gov.uk/infoabout/scco/index.htm.
|